Freelance Journalist Wins £8,360 In Holiday Pay Case

Employment Law & HR Updates, Straight To Your Inbox

Covering topics to help you effectively manage your employees.

Although those working on a freelance basis aren’t usually entitled to holiday pay, a freelance journalist was awarded the right to holiday pay at an employment tribunal in Scotland.

The claimant, journalist David Walsh, was employed by Scotsman Publications Ltd on a casual basis. Despite this, he was entitled to holiday pay as a ‘worker.’ Scotsman Publications Ltd disputed this, stating that he was defined as ‘self-employed’ in the freelance contract between himself and the company.

However, the National Union of Journalists (NUJ), who fought the case for Mr Walsh, were successful, resulting in the journalist receiving £8,360. Not only has the case been a huge success for David Walsh himself, but it will have massive implications for hundreds of other freelance journalists.

Freelance Journalist Wins £8,360 In Holiday Pay Case

Scotsman Publications Ltd was the holding company of a number of newspapers in Scotland, including Edinburgh Evening News, Scotland on Sunday, and The Scotsman. However, it was sold to Johnston Press in 2005. The company has since filed for administration, with JPIMedia acquiring the assets.

John Toner, who is the national organiser for the NUJ in Scotland, has stated that NUJ were always confident that they would win the case because the contract did not reflect the working relationship between Mr. Walsh and Scotsman Publications Ltd.

As the agreement is still in use by JPIMedia, it is likely that there are going to be a number of implications for any other freelancers that work for the business on a casual basis.

Reduce your hR Headaches

We specialise in fixed-fee Employment Law & HR services.

About the author

James Rowland

Account Services


James is on the Business Development & Account Management team at Neathouse Partners and regularly posts articles surrounding issues in HR & Employment Law, including case law & legislation updates. If you have a particular issue you would like addressed, feel free to drop James an email, and he will be happy to offer his assistance.

Free Resources

Free Employment Law & HR Managers Manual

free Contract of Employment template

Free Employment Contract Review