Short answer: Construction firms face employment risks across their workforce, including labour they do not treat as employees. CIS registration does not decide employment status. Umbrella company tax liability, right to work checks, project-end dismissals and site conduct all need clear processes.
Neathouse Partners supports construction firms with practical HR, employment law and health and safety advice. This guide focuses on Great Britain; employment law in Northern Ireland differs.
The Construction Industry Scheme is a tax deduction scheme. Paying a subcontractor under CIS does not establish that they are self-employed for employment rights purposes.
A labour-only subcontractor who works for you week after week, under your supervisor, with your tools and no genuine right to send a substitute may be a worker or employee. Status depends on the actual relationship, not simply the label in the contract.
| Status | Main rights |
|---|---|
| Self-employed | Contractual rights; health and safety protection and, in some cases, discrimination protection. |
| Worker | Paid holiday, minimum wage and working time protections, subject to the applicable rules. |
| Employee | Worker rights plus statutory notice, redundancy pay and unfair dismissal protection, subject to qualifying requirements and exceptions. |
Holiday pay claims can follow misclassification. Audit your regular subcontractors and check that your employment contracts and contractor documents reflect working arrangements.
Since 6 April 2026, HMRC can recover umbrella company PAYE underpayments from another party in the labour supply chain. This is the agency that contracts with the end client or, where no agency is involved, the end client itself.
The HMRC umbrella company guidance covers PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance responsibilities. Using an agency does not remove the need to understand how labour is engaged and paid.
Map your supply chain, identify every umbrella company involved and carry out documented checks. Do not assume that due diligence alone removes a statutory liability.
You must carry out compliant right to work checks where the rules place that responsibility on your business. For subcontracted or agency labour, establish the legal engagement arrangements and who must complete and retain the checks.
Use the current Home Office employer guidance rather than assuming that site induction or a subcontractor's assurance provides a statutory excuse. Civil penalties can reach £60,000 per illegal worker.
Build responsibility checks into procurement and site induction. Confirm that each operative is permitted to do the work concerned, arrange follow-up checks where required and retain evidence securely. Take advice if responsibility within a supply chain is unclear.
Unpaid lay-offs require a lawful basis, such as an applicable contractual right or the employee's consent. Without that authority, sending employees home unpaid can breach their contracts and create unlawful deduction from wages or constructive dismissal risks.
Review lay-off clauses before work dries up. Take advice before relying on custom and practice, and check statutory guarantee pay and any right to claim redundancy after a qualifying period of lay-off or short-time working.
The end of a project can result in a dismissal, often because of redundancy where the requirement for work has reduced. Expiry and non-renewal of a fixed-term contract also count as a dismissal in law.
Consult, use fair selection where needed, consider suitable work on other sites and confirm the outcome in writing. Follow a fair redundancy process rather than treating the project end as an automatic termination without employment obligations.
The government has announced a reduction in the ordinary unfair dismissal qualifying period to six months, expected in January 2027. Check commencement and transitional rules before relying on that timetable. Some automatically unfair dismissal protections apply without a qualifying period.
Construction firms should address harassment risks involving their own employees and people from other businesses on a shared site. The Equality Act 2010 framework includes a preventative duty concerning sexual harassment; the precise duties and defences must be assessed under the provisions in force.
Set site conduct rules with the principal contractor, train supervisors, make reporting straightforward and act promptly on complaints. Include third-party risks in your assessments rather than assuming another contractor will deal with them.
Neathouse Partners helps you develop HR policies and procedures that give managers a practical framework for handling complaints and site conduct.
The Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 place duties on clients, designers and contractors. Your responsibilities depend on your role and include planning, managing and monitoring construction work safely.
Keep site-specific risk assessments under review, provide appropriate training and supervision, and coordinate with other dutyholders.
Dismissing an employee for a protected health and safety reason can be automatically unfair from day one. Qualifying claims under section 100 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 are not subject to the ordinary compensatory award cap. Whether protection applies depends on the statutory conditions and facts.
For help with risk assessments, documentation and safe systems of work, explore our health and safety advice service.
No. Employment status depends on how the work is done, not on the tax scheme. A person paid under CIS may still qualify as a worker or employee for employment rights purposes.
You can be if you are the end client and no agency is involved. Where an agency contracts with you to supply the workers, HMRC's rules generally place the relevant responsibility on that agency. Check the actual supply chain.
Establish who is legally responsible under the rules applying to the engagement. Do not assume that subcontracting removes every obligation, or that a general site ID check is a compliant right to work check. Obtain advice where the arrangement is unclear.
Neathouse Partners provides fixed-fee employment law support for employers, including advice on contracts, workforce changes and dismissals.
Our outsourced HR support helps you manage day-to-day people issues with advice tailored to your business.
For construction HR and health and safety support, get a quote or speak to one of our experts about the support you need.
Reviewed November 2026. General guidance, not legal or tax advice. Check the law and commencement arrangements applying to your situation before acting.